本文轉貼自PTT
台灣最大的本土社群網站
分享這篇文章到Facebook、Google+或噗浪！


 作者  IoverIover (評論最專業)                                看板  Gossiping 
 標題  [問卦] "我難過"為何可以成為無法複刻經典？                              
 時間  Tue Mar 26 01:09:52 2013                                               
───────────────────────────────────────

這首歌少說紅了十年，是華人歌壇至今仍無法跨越的一道鴻溝

請問資深板友，這首歌可以成為神曲的要素到底有哪些呢？

小妹稍微解析一下，希望大家可以幫我補充

1、歌曲難度之高，需要由五位實力派歌手才有辦法詮釋。也就是說單獨如張學友、黎明、
　 劉德華、郭富城這四大天王，也很難詮釋，因為四大天王還是少了一個。


2、歷年各大選秀節目，根本就沒半個人敢挑戰這首世界名曲，出場率極低，意謂著沒人
　 大家只願意把它擺在心裡，任何人敢唱它就是毀謗它，因為再也不可能唱的比原唱好\
了　


3、僅僅三個字'我難過'，就把男女之間的愛恨情仇娓娓道來，言簡意賅比一些陳腔濫調，
　 硬要用華麗文字來描述的歌詞，這更彰顯它的樸實無華。


我想一定有其他小妹沒有發現的地方，我難過真的算是空前絕後的神曲嗎?

還是有哪一首歌可以超越經典中的經典呢?

感謝版友的分享，請搭配這首歌閱讀
kiwidoit:http://ppt.cc/Pusn 神支援

感謝阿扁哥的分享，看到這mv，讓我失眠了，只有5566的我難過能讓我難過
abian:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Ii0kpKi8kI


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 1.174.35.7
→ uhmeiouramu:我難過的是                                          03/26 01:10
推 DASHOCK:因為以前看五六偶像劇的都在上PTT  僅此而已               03/26 01:10
→ williamoleeo:曲好聽，因為是小剛作曲的，小剛本人唱的打趴某團體   03/26 01:10
推 QoiiwWe:放棄你放棄愛                                            03/26 01:10
推 Yada:只能推 5566得第一                                          03/26 01:10
噓 bobobola:明明就是很好唱的芭樂歌                                 03/26 01:10
→ aaaaa66666:放棄你放棄愛                                         03/26 01:10
→ clamperni:阿 我忘記怎麼唱了                                     03/26 01:10
推 abc06:認真的廢文 推                                             03/26 01:10
→ hydes:我不難過                                                  03/26 01:10
推 w1230319:最近失戀 聽了很有感觸                                  03/26 01:10
→ kiwidoit:我現在還是天天聽我難過....                             03/26 01:11
推 kimo6414:你的56ID呢                                             03/26 01:11
→ ryan666:需要由五位實力派歌手!?你沒聽過孟哲和紹偉獨唱對吧        03/26 01:11
噓 r02182828:沒有56ID發56文就得噓                                  03/26 01:11
→ Sevorlaga:好文  !!!                                             03/26 01:11
→ DASHOCK:紹偉本職是打籃球                                        03/26 01:12
推 ray90910:選秀節目沒有人唱這首讓我覺得很意外                     03/26 01:12
噓 joekiss:沒有56也敢問聖歌 噓屎你                                 03/26 01:12
推 kkessherry:我難過的是放棄你放棄愛放棄的夢被打碎 忍住悲哀~       03/26 01:12
噓 whiteadam:你ㄉ56 ID呢                                           03/26 01:12
→ abian:那一年默默無言只能選擇離開...                             03/26 01:12
噓 kiwidoit:這首去去KTV必點的歌曲吧..                              03/26 01:13
推 Colossus:神曲難度太高了,Jay的我還有聽人比賽唱過,這首沒人敢挑戰  03/26 01:13
噓 ryan666:紹偉是踢足球的吧?                                       03/26 01:13
推 miwy:因為這篇又重聽了一次.....                                  03/26 01:13
噓 PPmYeah:走過21世紀 估計是全人類歷史上最偉大的非物質資產         03/26 01:14
→ kiwidoit:http://ppt.cc/Pusn 神支援                              03/26 01:14
推 aaaaa66666:我以為 是成全 你卻說你更不明白                       03/26 01:14
推 JoshBeckeet:那一年默默無言.......                               03/26 01:14
推 chevalierxd:的確是神曲                                          03/26 01:15
推 tiny5566:我以為 是成全 你卻說你更不愉快                         03/26 01:15
推 seabox:5566踢掉肖欸跟肥哲就完美了                               03/26 01:15
推 bobobola:這首去ktv點會被笑吧                                    03/26 01:15
※ 編輯: IoverIover      來自: 1.174.35.7           (03/26 01:15)
推 abian:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Ii0kpKi8kI
                03/26 01:16
推 aquariusx:必點歌曲                                              03/26 01:17
推 NT520:太中肯了!!                                                03/26 01:17
推 terop:想知道為什麼我昨天半夜只想買一罐台啤卻在全家待了五分鐘嗎  03/26 01:18
→ abian:我難過 + MVP情人 ，方能得到最佳視覺感官體驗               03/26 01:18
→ terop:因為廣播剛好放了這首歌 讓我在全家裡晃來晃去只為了聽完     03/26 01:18
→ abian:不想知道                                                  03/26 01:18
推 miwy:樓上該不會剛好全家再放這首歌 聽完才走?                     03/26 01:18
推 chevalierxd:我難過的是放棄你 放棄愛                             03/26 01:19
→ terop:這首歌...                                                 03/26 01:19
※ 編輯: IoverIover      來自: 1.174.35.7           (03/26 01:19)
→ williamoleeo:http://tinyurl.com/apd6nwa 好聽多了，哼哼=..=      03/26 01:19
→ orz007:幹  剛剛聽了一次  我哭了  最後太感人了                   03/26 01:20
推 terop:可是我腦中浮現的是這版本                                  03/26 01:21
→ terop:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YH6FxVFrg68
                03/26 01:21
推 stevely:太感人了                                                03/26 01:26
→ Dragonz:旋律普通聽過也沒什麼印象...                             03/26 01:29
推 bobobola:樓上 看看就好 一堆人反串你還當真                       03/26 01:30
推 jason050117:反串成功                                            03/26 01:31
推 srxcomtx:幹 聽完我難過我都哭了 我真的很難過 再補個幹            03/26 01:34
→ MACROSSOVA:居然沒有56酥情神曲-存在                              03/26 01:35
→ MACROSSOVA:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hqty0e-KiPE          03/26 01:35
推 teddygoodgoo:幹...本來還好，可是PTT上幾年後，我已無法忘懷此歌   03/26 01:39
→ Godmyfriend:可惡  淚如雨下                                      03/26 01:50
噓 bestlove5566:什麼華人歌壇 是全世界都無法跨越的鴻溝好嗎          03/26 01:50
推 ohmypigg:推樓上 我也被洗腦~~    56不能亡                        03/26 01:50
推 kiwidoit:誰敢汙辱5566我第一個跟他...                            03/26 01:50
推 Homepage:                        修幹                           03/26 02:03
推 opp580:這世上除了羅禮士 沒人有能力復刻(推眼鏡                   03/26 02:14
噓 ohshit5566:誰買啦出了你一定不會買無聊廢文                       03/26 02:35
推 kstopplayer:每個晚上睡覺前必聽的神曲，不聽我還睡不著            03/26 02:50
→ selfet:kerker                                                   03/26 04:23
推 Elephant5566:這文章真的有夠廢 足堪表率                          03/26 04:59
推 sese5566:56必推                                                 03/26 07:25
推 Rusifer:http://ppt.cc/,_et 感商                                 03/26 07:37
→ Rusifer:終於明白 56魂                                           03/26 07:37
推 rainy1:還有好久不見啊！！只有56能超越56！                       03/26 08:15
推 hellosoap:我難過                                                03/26 08:54
噓 wwman:E0４他娘的　我再也沒辦法反串推我難過了　噁心爆了          03/26 08:58
推 lindviorair:ptt聖歌                                             03/26 09:06
推 TKW5566:5566永遠第一名!!!T___T                                  03/26 09:20
推 ji3g4zpgp:56不能亡阿!!!!!!!!!!!!                                03/26 10:57
推 m0a0r0k30304:56不能亡                                           03/26 13:35
推 cp9cm:5566得第一                                                03/26 14:47
噓 Hamazura:ID 沒56  失敗                                          03/26 15:22

----本文使用PCMAN+BBI轉貼----


※ 新版PCMAN開放測試中，新增功能：    



用PCMAN+BBI連回PTT原文